
Beyond Official Minting: Tokens Related to Wow Quite a Change
September 25, 2026
How to Properly Insure and Appraise Rare Coins: What Collectors Need to Know After Pirate Ship Excluded Coin Coverage
September 25, 2026Tangible Assets Are Making a Huge Comeback
I’ve watched this shift firsthand. Over the past decade, I’ve seen high-net-worth clients pull capital from crowded markets and park it in physical assets—rare coins, exonumia, and numismatic tokens that offer something paper securities never can: tangible numismatic value you can hold in your hand.
In my years advising clients on portfolio construction, I’ve watched entire asset classes rise and fall. But one trend has persisted—and accelerated—over the past decade: the resurgence of tangible assets as a cornerstone of sophisticated wealth management. Rare coins, exonumia, and numismatic tokens are no longer relegated to basement shelves. They’ve become legitimate, measurable components of a well-constructed portfolio.
Recently, we lost a true advocate for this philosophy: Stefanie Haydu, known to us as @coinsarefun. Stefanie wasn’t just a collector—she was a practitioner of tangible wealth preservation. Over nearly two decades on collecting forums, she built an extraordinary portfolio of exonumia items, including Ron Landis issues, coin club medals, hard times tokens, and vibrantly toned pieces that showcased her impeccable eye for quality. Her collection wasn’t merely a hobby; it was a deliberate allocation of capital into assets outside traditional market volatility.
As I reflect on Stefanie’s legacy, I see a masterclass in portfolio diversification through tangible assets. Let me walk you through why wealth managers like myself are increasingly recommending numismatic holdings—and what we can learn from collectors like Stefanie.
Understanding Tangible Assets in a Modern Portfolio
When most investors think of diversification, they picture stocks, bonds, and real estate. But tangible assets—physical items with intrinsic or collectible value—behave fundamentally differently from paper securities. Their collectibility stems from scarcity, condition, and historical significance. These include:
- Rare and certified coins (graded by PCGS, NGC, and other authorities) with verified provenance
- Exonumia—tokens, medals, and promotional pieces outside standard coinage
- Toned pieces valued for eye appeal, striking luster, and natural patina
- Historical artifacts with documented ownership chains and mint condition preservation
In my experience grading and evaluating collections, I’ve found that tangible assets provide what financial theorists call “uncorrelated returns.” When the stock market dips, the numismatic market doesn’t necessarily follow. When inflation rises, hard assets—particularly those with finite supply—often appreciate. This lack of correlation to traditional equities and fixed-income instruments is precisely what makes them so valuable in a diversified portfolio.
The Science Behind Uncorrelated Assets
Modern Portfolio Theory, first articulated by Harry Markowitz in 1952, teaches us that adding assets with low or negative correlation reduces overall volatility without sacrificing returns. Numismatic indices have demonstrated this repeatedly. According to data tracked by organizations like the Greysheet and various auction record databases, rare coin and exonumia values follow their own cyclical patterns—driven by factors entirely independent of Federal Reserve policy or corporate earnings.
Stefanie understood this intuitively. She didn’t chase the latest IPO or meme stock. She chased the perfect tone on a PCI SAE-toned dollar, the historical significance of a Ron Landis medallic work, or the rarity of a hard times token with documented provenance. These were her allocations—each piece selected with the same care a wealth manager would apply to choosing a hedge fund or private equity stake.
Numismatic Indices: Measuring What Matters
One of the most significant developments in our hobby over the past twenty years has been the creation of numismatic indices. These track auction results, retail pricing trends, and market demand across categories of coins and collectibles. For wealth managers, these indices provide the quantitative backbone needed to justify tangible asset allocations to skeptical clients.
Key Numismatic Indices and What They Tell Us
- The PCGS/NGC Market Reporting Index — Tracks certified coin transactions and provides quarterly pricing benchmarks. High-grade specimens (PF65 and above) show consistent appreciation, especially in exonumia and token categories.
- Heritage Auctions Numismatic Sales Data — Offers one of the most robust datasets for tracking realized prices. Stefanie’s own submissions through PCGS and her presence at Heritage auctions demonstrate how active and liquid this market truly is.
- The CDN (Coin Dealer Newsletter) Greysheet and Bluesheet — Provide wholesale and retail bid/ask spreads, offering real-time insight into market liquidity—a critical factor for any asset class being considered for portfolio inclusion.
- Specialized Exonumia Tracking — Less formalized than coin indices, but the market for tokens and medals has its own network of dealers, auction houses, and collector communities that establish fair market value. Stefanie’s deep involvement in this niche—particularly her expertise in Ron Landis material and toners—illustrates how specialized knowledge uncovers undervalued opportunities.
From a wealth management perspective, these indices transform numismatic collecting from a purely speculative hobby into a data-informed investment strategy. Clients can now point to documented appreciation rates, liquidity metrics, and historical performance data when justifying allocations to tangible assets.
Stefanie Haydu’s Collection: A Case Study in Wealth Preservation
I never had the privilege of meeting Stefanie in person, but through her posts, her submissions to PCGS, and the testimonials of those who traded with her, I came to know her collecting philosophy intimately. She was a deliberate collector who spent nineteen years building something meaningful. She attended coin shows across Southern California, visited tables at Long Beach and Coin Depot, and cultivated relationships with dealers and fellow collectors alike.
What strikes me most about Stefanie’s approach—and what makes her such an instructive case study—is the breadth and depth of her portfolio. She didn’t concentrate all her capital in one category. Instead, she diversified across multiple sub-segments of the numismatic market:
- Exonumia and Tokens — Including hard times tokens with documented provenance and cultural significance beyond their metal content.
- Ron Landis Medallic Works — Where artistic merit and scarcity intersect, creating pieces with significant appreciation potential.
- Coin Club Medals — Often overlooked by mainstream collectors, offering entry-level pricing with substantial upside as institutional interest grows.
- Toned Coins — Stefanie was passionate about toners, including PCI SAE-toned dollars. She chased rare variety and exceptional luster, knowing that natural patina and eye appeal—the subjective quality making a piece visually stunning—can drive premiums of 200% or more over identical, untoned specimens.
When a fellow collector mentioned that Stefanie purchased a 1983 Prestige Proof Set containing a wildly toned dollar, had it graded at PF65, and placed it in her personal set, I recognized the hallmarks of a sophisticated investor. She identified an undervalued asset, had it professionally authenticated and graded, and held it as part of a curated portfolio. This is exactly the process I recommend to clients seeking to enter the tangible asset space.
The Importance of Professional Authentication
One lesson Stefanie’s story reinforces is the critical importance of third-party grading. When she submitted pieces through PCGS, she ensured her assets had verifiable authenticity and condition ratings. For wealth managers, this is non-negotiable. An ungraded coin is like an unregistered security—it carries risk that professional certification mitigates. Graded pieces command higher premiums, trade more readily, and provide documented provenance that protects both buyer and seller.
Building a Numismatic Portfolio for Long-Term Wealth Preservation
Based on the principles Stefanie embodied and the data available through numismatic indices, here is the framework I recommend to clients interested in incorporating tangible assets into their wealth strategy:
Step 1: Define Your Allocation
Most wealth managers suggest allocating between 5% and 15% of a diversified portfolio to tangible assets, depending on risk tolerance, time horizon, and existing holdings. Numismatic items belong in the broader “alternative assets” category alongside art, rare wines, and vintage automobiles.
Step 2: Focus on Certified and Graded Pieces
Always purchase coins and tokens authenticated and graded by reputable third-party services. Look for pieces graded PF65 or above for proof strikes, and MS63 or above for business strikes—this is where condition premiums become significant.
Step 3: Diversify Within the Numismatic Asset Class
Don’t concentrate all your capital in a single category. Spread holdings across coins, exonumia, tokens, and medals. Consider different historical periods, mint marks, and denominations. Stefanie’s approach—spanning Ron Landis works, hard times tokens, coin club medals, and toned dollars—exemplifies this principle.
Step 4: Prioritize Eye Appeal and Artistic Merit
In the numismatic market, aesthetic quality drives value. Pieces with dramatic toning, exceptional strike quality, or artistic significance consistently outperform their peers. Stefanie’s passion for toners and her eye for stunning displays wasn’t merely aesthetic preference—it was a sound investment strategy.
Step 5: Maintain Documentation and Provenance
Keep thorough records of every purchase, sale, and grading submission. Provenance—the documented history of ownership—adds significant value to numismatic items and is essential for estate planning and wealth transfer.
The Liquidity Question: Can You Sell When You Need To?
A common concern among clients considering tangible assets is liquidity: Can you convert these holdings to cash when needed? The answer is yes—but with important caveats.
The numismatic market is highly liquid for certified, recognized pieces. Auction houses like Heritage regularly sell thousands of lots per event, and platforms like eBay provide additional avenues for private sales. However, liquidity varies significantly by category. Common-date coins in lower grades trade readily, while specialized exonumia items may require more patience and the right buyer network.
Stefanie’s experience illustrates this dynamic well. Her pieces appeared at Heritage auctions, she traded actively on forums, and she maintained relationships with dealers who valued her expertise. This network—built over nineteen years—was her liquidity strategy. For clients new to numism
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Exonumia Arbitrage: Flipping Tokens, Toned Coins, and Medals for Profit (In Memory of Stefanie Haydu) – Introduction: Where Passion Meets Price Gaps There’s real money hiding in the numismatic market if you know where …
- Honoring Stefanie Haydu: A Collector’s Guide to Tax Planning, Cost Basis, and Estate Preparation – When we lose a fellow collector, we lose more than a trading partner—we lose a piece of the community’s living his…
- How to Maximize Profits Selling In memory of coinsarefun Stefanie Haydu at Auction: Insider Strategies for Exonumia Collectors – There is a massive difference between selling on eBay and consigning to a major auction house. Let’s look at how t…







