
Inherited a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel? MS66, PR66, or PF67—Grade It Before You Sell
October 5, 2026
How to Insure and Appraise a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel: PR66 or MS66
October 5, 2026Selling a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel on eBay and consigning it to a major auction house are not the same event. A marketplace listing offers reach. A professionally cataloged auction brings specialist bidders to the table, organizes bidding around clear condition notes, and gives buyers confidence in what they are seeing. When Proof versus Mint State status remains uncertain, that difference can alter the numismatic value—and the hammer price—more dramatically than a dramatic photograph ever could. The first auction-house secret is simple: do not sell an attribution you have not earned.
The online forum debate captured the problem perfectly. One moment, the coin was being called MS66; the next, opinions ranged from PR65 and PR66 to PF67. Some collectors focused on the sharp rims, apparent mirrored fields, and clean surfaces. Others questioned the edge, a possible reverse-rim spot, and the limits of photography. That disagreement was not a failure of collecting. It was a vivid reminder that an exceptional coin cannot be graded responsibly from a handful of casual images.
My auction-house rule is simple: attribution before adjectives. I would ask whether the coin is genuinely a Proof, whether the rim mark is carbon, corrosion, or a planchet feature, which grading service assigned the certification, and what realistic prices apply to each possible outcome. Only then do photography, precise catalog notes, lot placement, timing, estimates, reserve, and fee structure come into play. Those auction-house choices can create competition among the right bidders and improve the hammer price. Inflated claims do the opposite. Eye appeal earns attention; sound attribution earns trust.
1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel: Proof or Mint State? The Online Grade Debate
Few United States coins carry as much collectibility as the 1913 Buffalo nickel. It was the denomination’s first year, and the Type 1 is the scarcer variety, with a lower mintage than the familiar Type 2. James Earle Fraser’s design places a Native American profile on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse. The key variety distinction lies in LIBERTY: it is arranged vertically at the right on Type 1 and horizontally on Type 2. For collectors, that is not trivia. Confusing the two varieties can undermine both confidence and numismatic value.
When cataloging the coin, the basic specifications matter:
- Date and variety: 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel
- Denomination: Five cents
- Composition: 75 percent copper and 25 percent nickel
- Weight: 5.2 grams
- Diameter: Approximately 21.2 millimeters
- Edge: Plain
- Mint: Philadelphia, with no mintmark
- Designer: James Earle Fraser
These specifications establish the coin’s identity, but they do not establish authenticity, mint condition, grade, or Proof status. Only close examination can support those claims. A catalog that identifies Type 1 as Type 2—or gives a Philadelphia coin a mintmark—immediately raises doubts. Professional auction staff verify the date, variety, and metal before the coin reaches a specialist or appears in the catalog.
The forum images appeared unusually sharp, yet the proposed grades differed by two full points. That gap is a warning, not a minor inconvenience. I will not allow a photo-only eye grade to drive a consignment. On a coin this important, the strike, luster, patina, rim structure, and possible Proof fabric deserve the same scrutiny as the date and edge.
Why Forum Grades Ranged From MS66 to PF67
Viewers were reading different visual clues. Some focused on the strong rim-to-field contrast and apparent absence of contact marks.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Inherited a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel? MS66, PR66, or PF67—Grade It Before You Sell – Inherited a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel? MS66, PR66, or PF67—grade it before you sell. I know the temptation. When an unf…
- Privy Marks and Provenance: How Eliasberg, Pogue, and Auction Records Add Value – A coin with a famous pedigree can command a substantial premium—sometimes even twice the price of an otherwise identical…
- Monster Toning or Artificial? Decoding Rainbow, Bag, and Album Toning on Graded Morgan Dollars (1878–1921) – Beautifully toned coins can bring serious premiums. But the line between admired natural color and artificial enhancemen…








