
1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Proof or Mint State? Auction Secrets for a Higher Hammer Price
October 5, 2026
Flipping a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel for Profit: PR66, MS66, or Details?
October 5, 2026I would never assume that a standard homeowner’s policy covers the full numismatic value of a rare coin collection. For a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel, the difference between MS66 and PR66 can be financially enormous. Proper coverage begins with an honest description—not a hoped-for grade.
A forum discussion about an unattributed 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel shows the problem clearly. The photographs inspired widely different guesses: MS66, PR65, PR66, even PR67. Some collectors saw proof fabric; others pointed to a spot on the reverse rim, uneven color, and the inability to examine the edge or verify the coin’s fabric. The owner planned to submit the coin to CACG, but no final result was reported.
For a collector, that uncertainty is part of the process. For an insurer, it is a valuation problem. A hoped-for PR66 is not an established PR66. Unless a recognized grading service confirms the classification and numerical grade, I would schedule, appraise, and describe the coin according to the evidence available on the valuation date.
1. Why the 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Is an Insurance Case Study
The 1913 issue marked the official debut of the Buffalo nickel, one of the most recognizable designs in United States numismatics. Whenever I appraise one, I begin with the basics. James Earle Fraser designed the obverse, while Charles E. Barber created the reverse. The five-cent coin was struck in cupro-nickel, consisting of 75 percent copper and 25 percent nickel, with a nominal weight of 5.25 grams and a diameter of approximately 21.2 millimeters.
The obverse makes the Type 1 identification decisive. LIBERTY appears in raised letters on the left side of the coin. It should not be confused with the 1913 Type 2, which has an incuse LIBERTY on the right. Type 2 is the rare variety here; a high-grade Type 1 proof tells a different scarcity story. Assuming the forum attribution is correct, the absence of a mint mark indicates a Philadelphia issue. Denver and San Francisco examples carry a D or S mint mark.
Philadelphia produced Type 1 nickels in substantial numbers, but proof survivors in the highest grades are far scarcer than ordinary examples in mint condition. Even when the variety itself is not rare, a top-grade survivor can be. PR66 and PF66 may be used under different grading-service conventions to describe a proof coin at the same numerical level. Neither designation authenticates a coin by itself; both must be supported by a recognized grading service.
That makes an appraisal especially sensitive to classification. A raw coin later certified PR66 may have a very different numismatic value from one certified MS66. A details grade caused by corrosion, a cleaning mark, or environmental damage can change the equation again. Strong strike, lively luster, and superior eye appeal can elevate one coin, while a spot or rim blemish may hold another back. The insurance schedule should reflect the coin’s actual status on a specific date—not the owner’s optimistic estimate.
What the Forum Actually Established
From the supplied discussion, I can describe a promising coin, but I cannot assign a final grade. The images suggested an unusually sharp example with possible proof characteristics. The observations included:
- Sharp, squared rims and a strong overall strike
- Fields that appeared proof-like under some lighting
- A possible carbon speck, corrosion spot, or environmental blemish near the reverse rim
- Questions about uneven color, prior cleaning, and the originality of the patina
- Limited views of the edge and insufficient full-size images
- Conflicting opinions ranging from MS66 to PR67
- A planned submission to CACG, with no final result reported
In my experience examining and insuring early Buffalo nickels, this is exactly the type of coin that needs a provisional description. The observations are useful, but they do not justify entering “PR66” on an insurance schedule as if a grader had already assigned it. Accurate protection depends on separating evidence from speculation.
2. Why a Homeowner’s Policy Usually Falls Short
A standard homeowner’s policy may provide limited blanket coverage for personal property, but that does not mean its declared limit represents the coin’s full replacement value. Coins, currency, jewelry, watches, cameras, and musical instruments are often subject to separate sublimits. Fine art, antiques, and collectibles may require a scheduled endorsement.
In addition, I would check how the policy treats:
- Property stored at home versus property kept elsewhere
- Theft versus fire, water, or accidental damage
- Scheduled individual items versus larger collections
- Actual cash value versus replacement cost
- Coins held in a home safe versus a bank safe-deposit box
- Travel, exhibitions, dealer consignments, grading submissions, and coins in transit
Actual cash value generally means the coin’s market value at the time of loss. Replacement cost may require the insured to purchase a substantially similar coin. That can mean buying another example from a dealer at retail prices rather than finding a comparable coin at auction. The distinction becomes especially important in a thin market, where an MS66 and PR66 may sell under very different terms. Even small differences in strike, luster, patina, or eye appeal can affect the price.
I recommend obtaining a policy written specifically for fine art and collectibles and confirming that numismatic coins are an expressly covered class of property. For an individual coin of meaningful value, an itemized schedule is safer than relying exclusively on a general collection limit. I would also use a written appraisal that explains provenance, rarity, condition, eye appeal, and recent comparable sales—not merely a value stated without support.
Questions to Ask the Insurer
Before this Buffalo nickel travels for grading or shipment, I would ask the insurer or broker:
- Is this raw coin covered at the stated value before grading?
- Is it covered while in the mail, at the grading company, or with a carrier?
- Does coverage continue if the service returns a lower grade?
- How would an increased value be handled if the coin is later certified at a substantially higher grade?
- Are auction shipments, dealer consignments, and temporary exhibitions covered?
- Is the policy written on a replacement-cost or actual-cash-value basis?
- Is there a separate limit for coins in storage?
- Does the policy cover coins held in a bank safe-deposit box?
- What security, fire-protection, inventory, and appraisal requirements apply?
Do not assume that a general policy provides full-value coverage merely because it lists personal property. The declarations, exclusions, endorsements, and valuation provisions control. If the answer is unclear, obtain written confirmation before the coin leaves your possession.
3. Build a Numismatic Schedule Before the Coin Moves
An insurance schedule is more than a list of purchase prices and dates. It gives a claims adjuster a clear way to identify the property, verify ownership, understand its condition, and distinguish it from every other coin in the collection. It should also record provenance—or state plainly that none is known.
For this possible 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel, I would include at least the following:
- Description: 1913 Type 1 five-cent Buffalo nickel, with the obverse LIBERTY on the left
- Issuer: United States
- Mint: Philadelphia, based on the absence of a visible mint mark and subject to verification
- Metal: Cupro-nickel, 75 percent copper and 25 percent nickel
- Weight: Nominal 5.25 grams
- Diameter: Approximately 21.2 millimeters
- Classification: Raw and ungraded; mint-state or proof status remains unresolved
- Grade: Unassigned unless a recognized grading service has issued a numerical grade
- Condition: Suspected spot near the first- or second-o’clock position on the reverse rim
- Color: Describe the coin’s patina and distinguish original toning from environmental or artificial color
- Holder:
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Proof or Mint State? Auction Secrets for a Higher Hammer Price – Selling a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel on eBay and consigning it to a major auction house are not the same event. A market…
- Inherited a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel? MS66, PR66, or PF67—Grade It Before You Sell – Inherited a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel? MS66, PR66, or PF67—grade it before you sell. I know the temptation. When an unf…
- Privy Marks and Provenance: How Eliasberg, Pogue, and Auction Records Add Value – A coin with a famous pedigree can command a substantial premium—sometimes even twice the price of an otherwise identical…








