
How to Photograph Coin Luster: An Axial Lighting and Macro Masterclass
September 25, 2026Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Exonumia Connected to the Stefanie Haydu Collection Without Overpaying
September 25, 2026Not every coin—or medal, token, or other piece of exonumia—makes a safe blank for jewelry. Before I consider turning Stefanie Haydu’s favorite piece into a coin ring, I need to know what it is made of and how it will endure the forming process. The exonumia item remembered in connection with Stefanie, the longtime collector and forum member @coinsarefun, was reportedly one of her favorites. Yet the forum account provides no date, weight, diameter, thickness, edge description, or metal composition. I would never promise crafting potential from a photograph or a heartfelt association alone. Those missing facts come first.
My answer must be conditional. The piece could have excellent jewelry potential if it is thick, ductile silver or a silver-copper alloy, with strong eye appeal and little numismatic value at risk. I would treat it as a poor candidate if it is plated, brittle, unusually thin, historically significant, or deeply tied to Stefanie’s collection. A skillfully made memorial ring can honor her memory. An impulsive alteration can irreversibly destroy its numismatic value, provenance, and collectibility. That distinction matters to me.
Why Crafting Potential Requires More Than a Crafter’s Eye
Stefanie Haydu was remembered by fellow collectors for her enthusiasm, her eye for vibrant toning, and her interest in coin-club medals, hard times tokens, Ron Landis issues, and other unusual exonumia. She cared about each object’s history and shared striking photographs of her collection. To me, that blend of artistic taste and historical curiosity raises the stakes. This is not just a piece of metal waiting for a mandrel.
Exonumia is a broad category that includes medals, tokens, badges, chatelaines, commemorative pieces, and other non-currency objects. Unlike a conventional silver dollar or half dollar, an exonumia piece may have been cast rather than struck, layered rather than homogeneous, or made from an alloy intended for decoration instead of repeated deformation. A crisp strike and attractive patina can add eye appeal, but they do not prove that the object can survive ring forming. Some pieces are remarkably tough; others crack, split, or delaminate under pressure.
- Known from the discussion: the object was one of Stefanie’s favorites, and it appeared in an ANA Numismatist publication.
- Not established in the text: whether it is a coin, medal, token, or commercial issue.
- Not established: whether it contains silver, its precise silver percentage, and whether copper, nickel, zinc, or a plated surface is present.
- Not established: whether its diameter, thickness, relief, and edge are suitable for a wearable ring.
A beautiful object is not automatically a good blank, and a collectible object is not automatically safe to alter.
Before any tool touches the piece, I would document both faces, record its exact dimensions, study the edge, and establish its provenance. I would also note any remaining luster, the character of its patina, and whether the object is genuinely in mint condition. An attribution to a rare variety, original luster, stable toning, or a documented place in Stefanie’s collection could increase its numismatic value and collectibility. Those qualities deserve preservation, not casual experimentation.
Silver Content: The First Number a Crafter Must Know
Common silver benchmarks
Silver content affects color, density, tarnish behavior, and—most importantly for this project—how an alloy responds to forming. These familiar benchmarks help me frame the question, but I never assume one applies to an unidentified token or medal.
- .900 silver: Many classic United States dimes, quarters, and half dollars, along with Morgan and Peace dollars, contain 90 percent silver and 10 percent copper. The copper adds strength, making this alloy generally more workable than pure silver.
- .925 sterling: Sterling contains 92.5 percent silver and 7.5 percent other metals, traditionally copper. Widely used in jewelry, it can form beautifully when the craftsman anneals it at the right stages.
- .999 silver: Modern American Silver Eagles are .999 fine silver. Their bright color and luster are appealing, but high purity also means greater softness, faster work hardening, and a stronger tendency toward scratches and dents.
- Copper, bronze, brass, nickel, and steel: Many tokens and medals fall outside familiar silver-coin alloys. Some copper alloys are highly ductile, while some nickel alloys are tough. Plated or laminated pieces, however, can separate when bent.
Silver content alone does not determine whether a ring will survive. A thin .900-silver token may resist forming more than a thicker sterling piece, while hard bronze can crack at a stress point. Alloy, microstructure, thickness, and prior work history all matter. I want to understand the whole blank before I ask it to become jewelry.
How I test without guessing
- Begin with a close visual inspection. I look for a silver-white surface, copper-colored wear, plating seams, casting pits, laminate lines, and an edge that differs from the faces.
- Measure its weight, diameter, and thickness. I compare those figures with known issues, but a matching diameter never proves the same composition.
- Use a magnet as a screening tool. Strong attraction indicates ferromagnetic material, but no attraction does not prove silver. Many silver alloys are nonmagnetic.
- Consider X-ray fluorescence testing. XRF can identify surface composition, but it reads mainly where the instrument reaches and may miss a plated core or layered construction.
- Use specific-gravity or other bulk testing when appropriate. Holes, inclusions, cavities, and plating can skew the results, so I never rely on one test in isolation.
- Seek a qualified laboratory for valuable material. A destructive file test or sectioning has no place on an object with numismatic, historical, or personal significance.
I keep composition and value as separate questions. A high-silver piece may still be common, damaged, or unsuitable for jewelry. A base-metal token may be historically important and full of eye appeal without carrying much bullion value. Either way, I assess the object as a collector and historian before I think of it as a blank.
Hardness, Thickness, and the Ring-Sizing Problem
A coin ring is not simply a coin with a hole punched through it. The process normally creates a central opening, controls stress around that opening, raises and shapes the rim, and draws or presses the blank over a mandrel. The metal must stretch and flow without tearing. It must also retain enough wall thickness after forming to remain comfortable and durable in everyday wear.
Soft silver versus work-hardened alloy
Annealed pure silver is comparatively soft and easy to shape, but it marks readily and may thin out in stretched areas. A silver-copper alloy is usually stronger and better suited to repeated forming, provided I anneal it at the correct stage. As silver and its alloys are worked, they become harder and less ductile—a process called work hardening. I may need to anneal between operations, clean the surface carefully, and reassess the forming before continuing.
Unknown exonumia demands even more caution. A cast piece may hide porosity or internal flaws that are invisible on the surface. A plated piece may expose base metal when its coating cracks. A hard, high-zinc brass can behave nothing like a copper-rich bronze, and a brittle alloy may fail around the punch or along the path of greatest stress.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- The Buyer’s Mindset: Why an 1881-CC Morgan Counterfeit Case Reveals What Makes Collectors Overpay – What makes a collector reach for a wallet and ignore a warning? With coins, price is never explained by silver weight, r…
- Can You Still Find Treasure at Flea Markets and Pawn Shops? Morgan Dollars, Haggling, and Double-Fake Detection – The easy Morgan dollar find is gone, but the hunt is not. Can you still find treasure at flea markets and pawn shops? My…
- Using the Spice Girls 2026 UK Commemorative Gold Proof Coin to Teach Children About History, Pop Culture, and Numismatics – There’s a moment I live for. You hold a coin in your hand — real metal, real history — and you watch a child’…







